
CHML's Car Doctor JOHN BOOTH wants to hear your questions, comments or just a hello! Email John at
doc@womensgarage.com!
Friday March 5:
Question:
I have a 1998R, 47,000-mile MGF 1•8 VVC with a good specification (leather, air-con, CD changer and so on). It is in excellent condition and has been serviced diligently by official MG dealers, but I don't find it much fun. A local trader has offered me $12,000 in part-exchange against either a BMW Z3 2•8 (which I like, although it has been serviced only three times during its six-year, 17,000-mile life) or a 2003 Mercedes SLK 230K (43,000 miles, but not brilliant to drive). Am I being offered the right amount for the MG? Is the Z3 a safe bet? Should I forget the idea of the SLK?
Peter in North Carolina
ANSWER:
You have been offered a fair price for the MG. If you want a rewarding drive, look at the latest Mazda Miata six-speed Sport. A Z3 is a touring roadster and the SLK - at its best as a 3•2 V6 with six-speed manual box - is even more so. The BMW 2•8 can suffer cylinder bore lining problems, too.
Good Luck!
Dr. John Booth - "The Car Doctor"